Public, Private or Homeschool???

Choosing the right school for your kids isn’t a hot topic in the Financial Independence/Financial Freedom community, but it probably should be. Public, private or home schooling, each comes with its own financial implications that need to be factored into your overall plan in achieving FF.

For anyone planning on having kids, or with young children approaching school age, the decision on where to send your kids to school is a big one. Whether you are a fan of good old fashioned public school, gunning for the elite status of a private school, or thinking about trying your hand at home schooling, each option has its own merits along with some disadvantages worth considering.

The difficult part in making a choice like that, is that it is extremely difficult to forecast what you will choose BEFORE you have kids. We all like to think we know what we will choose for them, but somehow when those tiny humans come along, they have a way of shaking our priorities to the very core of our being. Sometimes turning our life perspectives directly on their head.

If you don’t have kids, but plan to have them, you’re probably shaking your head right now. Thinking: “Nope, I know exactly how I’m going to raise my kids, and nothings gonna change when they do come along.” I hate to break it to you, but you’re wrong. I know this, because I had the same thoughts, and I learned very quickly just how wrong I was.

If you are a parent reading this, you’re probably nodding along right now, reminiscing about your pre-kid life views.

No where was I more wrong than when it comes to how I would want to school our kids.

When our youngest started school, the thought about where he should go to school wasn’t really a question to me. As two full time working parents, we picked our home in a public school catchment that we liked, and outside of looking at the possibility of a French Immersion School, we didn’t give it much further thought.

To me, it all made sense. The public school was highly ranked, in close proximity to our home. I had visions of us walking him to and from school, with him reaching a point where he could make that journey independently, and making long lasting friendships with kids who not only went to the same school, but also lived in our immediate neighbourhood. No crazy commutes, no driving extended distances for arranged playdates, the kiddo’s could play out in our neighbourhood, it all seemed very idyllic.

At least it did, until last year…….when suddenly, with my focus no longer on achieving FF, I suddenly began to question every aspect of our decision. Without work, driving our kids to a private school was well within our grasp, doing home schooling was also completely feasible, and now that public school wasn’t just the default option, we started really asking ourselves if it was what we wanted for our kids.

Around that same time our son started showing the signs of not wanting to go to school. Yes I know, that’s very typical, the majority of of kids don’t LOVE school. But as a former homeschooler myself, his complaints struck a chord with me. He hated how much time they spent doing nothing in class, he constantly told us how much he wished that his teacher would just tell him how much work he needed to do, and he could do it and leave. He told us about the regular fights (physical fights) kids would have in class and on the playground when they were supposedly being “supervised”. (Keep in mind, he was 8 at that time….we’re not even talking about middle school here).

As much as we felt, and do feel, that our son was going to a considerably above average school (when compared to other public schools), but there was still so much about what he was learning, how he was learning it, AND the social environment, that left us questioning if it was really the best use of nearly 50% of his weekday waking hours.

There’s no doubt, that from an FI perspective, public school is the most cost effective option for parents. But, the more Mike and I researched the topic, the more apparent it became that this was an area where the financial scope took a backseat. Not to say it wasn’t a consideration, financial feasibility should always be a consideration, but in this instance, we felt that it should be leading the way.

When we started to examine things more closely, it was clear that the public school curriculum was consistently lacking and regularly behind the times. With such a large beaurocracy, and major costs associated to curriculum changes, it’s difficult for public systems to keep their content and delivery methods current. One of the major cons is also the fact that when you have such large class sizes, content is delivered to the average, and likely not in a format that best suits your own child’s interests or learning style. And really, what more is a teacher to do? It’s pretty difficult to tailor the delivery to each individual child, as well as to challenge the brightest students but also adequately address students who are struggling or falling behind.

In general what we saw, and what I thin most people see, is that public school caters to the average. It molds kids to be average employees, obtain average jobs, and lead average lives. So if average is what any of us parents are shooting for, then the public school system is ideal.

Everything else aside, my biggest complaint with the public school system, is that it consistently fails to teach kids how to learn independently. It teaches them how to be spoon fed, and how to be shown what to do and when to do it.

All of these factors led us to begin examining private school options. I know many people who send their people to private schools, from faith-based to non-secular, even boarding schools. There is no doubt that private schools offer a lot that the public system can’t hold a candle too. But the higher up the chain you go in terms of curriculum, quality of staff, infrastructure, and class size, the bigger the price tag that comes with it. Even though we didn’t want to lead with the financial implications, it’s difficult to ignore the reality of annual tuition costs at private schools.

Here in Vancouver, that annual price tag ranges anywhere from $4000 (generally for faith based schools), all the way up to $50,000 for the elite of the elite. And that’s just tuition. Books, field trips, sports costs, bus fee’s, uniforms, are all added on top of that. After some hefty research, the school that caught my attention the most was $32,000 annually. Yikes! Times that by two kids, and either Mike or I would have to go back to work to swing it, or we would need to make some major lifestyle adjustments to make it happen. Definitely something that plays a major factor in anyone’s plan for Financial Freedom.

But while private schools offer some of the best facilities and equipment money can buy, it begs the question is it really the best option when it comes to educating your kids? Because many private schools receiving government funding in order to offset their tuition fee’s, the vast majority of them comply with the provincial curriculum where they are located. Which means that despite being in a fancier class room, with a smaller class size, and cooler gadgets, your kids are essentially learning the same content. Albeit with some nifty, gimmicky add-on content to draw parents in.

Even with all their upgrades, private schools still suffer from a lot of the same con’s of public school. Arguably, despite the uniforms, they have significantly higher potential for social pressures and undesirable influences when it comes to stuff (particularly if you are a middle class family sending your child to a school with a considerably wealthier clientele.) And they still suffer from the same problems as public school in that kids aren’t taught how to learn independently.

As someone who was homeschooled for the entirety of my education, long before it was “cool” to homeschool your kids, I have a somewhat unique experience and perspective to draw on when it comes to the homeschooling alternative. Ironically, even though I was homeschooled, I never thought I would homeschool my own kids. Selfishly, I recognized it as a ton of work, and I always thought I would be in a career that I wanted to heavily pursue.

I also had strong memories of regularly feeling like an outsider, like other kids thought I was weird because I was homeschooled. In hindsight, these concerns were likely more in my head than the other kids, but they were feelings I didn’t want my own children to experience.

In spite of those feelings, I will be forever grateful to my parents for making the decision to school my siblings and I at home. It’s given me some major advantages throughout my life.

When I was a kid, it was the awesome advantage of being able to sleep in, work for only a couple hours, and still get way more done than my friends in the public system. As a total night owl, I loved it.

As I got older, it was learning that because I controlled my time, if I finished all my work early, I got a much longer summer than my public school compadres. Often twice as long, or even more.

And as I got into my teens, it was the ability to pursue my aspirations of playing competitive hockey, moving away from home at 15, even being able to go and live in Australia and play hockey when I was just 17. Not to mention that because I could control my own school hours, I regularly had multiple jobs from the time I was 12 and up. These opportunities, and the experiences I drew from them, gave me a huge leg up when it came to developing work ethic, savings habits, and building independence.

I diligently saved my waitressing paycheques, bought my first condo, and took possession of it the  day I turned 18 years old. And from there, my hunger for financial knowledge and independence only grew.

I credit all of this to my parents. To their courage in breaking the mold and doing things differently, even under the scrutiny and judgement of many around them. It wasn’t easy for them. It was a major undertaking to keep three kids at home and do all the schooling. Not only did it mean sacrificing a second income for many years, it also meant my mother committing to being at home all the time with three little hellions. Doing all the regular heavy lifting a stay at home mom does, groceries, cooking, cleaning, yard work, laundry, (I could go on and on) WITHOUT that 6-7 hour break of the kids being in school. Yikes – makes me tired just thinking about it!

It also meant additional work for my Dad. He already had a full time job, and I can’t remember a day from my childhood where he didn’t regularly go above and beyond in putting in a full days work. Getting up at 5AM, heading out to work, and not getting off work until 5PM. But in spite of those long hours, he would regularly come home and help us out with our math lessons, patiently guiding us through any areas where we’d gotten stuck.

Aside from all the opportunities home schooling provided for me, my biggest takeaway will always be that it taught me how to learn and teach myself. The confidence to know that I don’t need to be shown, I can just figure it out. There have been so many times in my career where that single skill set has paid off in dividends. It’s a skill set I absolutely want to foster in my kids.

For anyone pursuing Financial Freedom, homeschooling can be a difficult option when you are still pursuing the dream. It likely translates to giving up a secondary income, and it’s major responsibility for any parent to undertake. For us in BC, it also doesn’t result in any type of government funding or tax credit, so purchasing curriculum content does result in additional costs. But it does allow you to have the leeway to build your own curriculum, and focus on the area’s that you feel are important, or that your child has particular interests in. The flexibility it offers from an individual learning standpoint are immense. Not to mention the quality time you get to spend with your kids, developing your relationship and instilling the values and skills that are important to your family. Like financial literacy for instance.

Even as I write this post, I’m struck by how on paper, homeschooling seems like the obvious choice for us, and yet I’m still hesitant to make the decision. I attribute that largely to a recognition of just how much work it is, and a nervousness of doing a good job! But really, if it’s such an important piece of my children’s foundation in life, why would I want to hand it over to someone else who won’t take nearly as much interest or ownership of the task?

For now, I plan to remain in the information gathering phase, identifying the pro’s and con’s of what’s out there, and weighing those factors against what is most important for our family. If you have your own thoughts or comments on this topic, or resources that you have found useful, please leave a comment or send me an e-mail!

For anyone in the FI world, I encourage you to heavily evaluate what you want for your kids education, and what aligns with your family values. Whatever the decision, it will factor in to any successful plan for Financial Freedom.

16 thoughts on “Public, Private or Homeschool???

  1. Most parents don’t consider the ramifications of what the children are seeing, hearing, and being exposed to in public schools. The natural rules of a home are subject to political interpretations and changes in the wind. One child might be punished for an infraction, but another child skates by. This sends very confusing messages to the students, and many rebel. A child in my room, who never did any work in the years previous, then little in mine (a bit more from what I was told), went on to the next grade having pretty much failed the grade. Realizing this, some kids in my class, who for a long time improved, stopped working in the 4th quarter. Why should they.\? They would pass no matter what.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. That would be incredibly frustrating and challenging as an educator. And yes, I have definitely noticed our oldest son regularly comes home with stories of double standards and mixed messages from one teacher to another. No doubt he finds it confusing and frustrating (he’s also a bit of a perfectionist so I think he has stronger reactions to it then other kids may). The upside is that he is talking about it – which provides a platform to discuss how inequalities of all shapes and sizes can present throughout life, and how he can choose to view those experiences (and hopefully learn from them).

      Challenging stuff though – and I hate to think of how it all impacts kids who don’t have sufficient support or strong parental relationships to fall back on when they are experiencing it. Having a number of teachers in my extended family, I have certainly learned a lot from them about the problems they see arising at school, particularly in the realm of parenting shortfalls – I would guess that you have a vast array of stories and experiences that have shaped your view on these topics!

      Like

      1. If you have the time, I would recommend home schooling for a time, perhaps a couple of years, and in addition to teaching things you know well, encourage him to write (i.e. stories, essays, and such, but let his interests lead the way), work on higher mathematics (I used to study the math books in college, then I knew most of the work before the teacher ever began), but also work on “hands-on” projects in the home. Museums, science and observatories, going to work with you to see what goes on, starting a small business, and such. During that time, he’ll have a more practical (useful) outlook and understand more in school. Take care.

        Liked by 2 people

      2. If you have the chance to read my site, you’ll see a lot from experience. I will be putting up one other article today, to demonstrate real world application that “ideas” can’t show unless realistically applied. Thanks for your efforts:-)

        Liked by 1 person

      3. It’s just one person’s perspective. I’m a work in progress. I have known teachers that can do and teach in ways I cannot, but they’re excellent in what they do. Good teachers each have something to offer, and if we don’t create a one-size-fits-all, kids will garner a lot from them. But thank you. I learn from others as much as I share. And some of what I use today came from understanding others, even from the students themselves.

        Liked by 2 people

  2. Great post. I found it thoughtful and introspective. I think I learn as much from others and my own understanding grows. Thank you so much. I wish to add a little. I think every child is different, and while one child might excel in a good public or private school, another benefits from being home where the pacing and way of learning fits better. But I want to add something key here, and it may seem off-topic in a sense, but it’s well worth considering for readers who are having similar considerations. This is an old story, but it will make an important point, something I will include on my site. *There was this boy who loved his parents. He was playing in the yard, and his father told him to stay, not leave. One of the boy’s friends happened by on a bicycle and asked him to go riding. “My dad told me to stay here,” said the boy. After some back and forth, the friend challenged the boy, saying “Oh, you’re father doesn’t really need you to stay. He just doesn’t trust you. Let’s go riding. It’ll be fun.” Well, after a few attempts, the boy got his bike and went riding. **What is the point here? The boy loves his parents, but the friend cast doubt into his mind, creating a divide between parents and child. Sending your kids to any program where others are in charge of their education is an important decision. No, we can’t worry about everything that might happen, but keeping the children home, educating them in the early years, will enforce a bond of love and understanding, communication which is so important. And I think that’s more important today than ever before. What will they teach your children? How do they manage classrooms and behaviors you would never tolerate? Confusion? Yes, they will get some socialization, but what will that look like? And when the children come home, after years of being in institutions that “reeducate” their understanding, cast doubt, and “friends” talk into their ears things you would never allow, before they’re strong enough to tell them to “take a hike”, what will that later look like? Sometimes, children will come to resent their parents for putting them in places where they don’t have the chance to be themselves. And that’s something to consider.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for taking the time to write such a thoughtful comment! I entirely agree with you that every child’s learning style and personality needs to be considered when making such an impactful decision. The story you included absolutely underscores how important it is to consider the environment and people who will have the biggest influences on your children, and their decisions, particularly when their maturity and understanding is not yet fully formed. Thanks again for your comment – very thought provoking 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

    2. @dolphinwrites: I fully agree with your stance on the importance of parental influence when your kids are young. It’s SO important!

      My oldest is in Grade 8, and it’s heartbreaking to see how far some of his classmates have fallen in the short months since starting high school. There’s vaping, drinking, inappropriate use of social media, and who knows what else.

      While it might be true that school environments foster these problems, I don’t believe outside influences are the root cause for these issues. I feel these issues actually start at home.

      The troubled children I know are very well-loved by their parents. But sadly, that’s not enough. They also need their parents’ focused, consistent (and skilled) time and attention—and not just when things go wrong. When these kids don’t get the right kind of attention from their parents, they turn to their peers. And that’s when they fall off the wagon.

      I strongly believe that “holding onto our kids” and building a deep connection with them every single day, from day one, inoculates them against much of these outside influences. I’ve naturally parented this way because it’s also the way I was parented. And I’ve seen that it works!

      I believe it lines up with what you believe too—so we’re in agreement there!

      But we differ a bit in that I think there are ways to avoid the issues you’ve pointed out, even if your child must attend school outside the home.

      Yes, homeschooling is a wonderful thing. (I wish I had the energy and temperament to do it!) However, sending your child to school doesn’t mean you’ll lose control of how they’ll turn out. If you build a strong connection with your kids, you’ll be there guiding them all the time—whether you’re physically there or not.

      Know that I leave this comment not to debate with you. I think we agree on pretty much everything. I just want to provide a slightly different view on the issue so that others might see it more fully.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Great comment @ESB_FI!! I think you zeroed in on a key component here. While homeschooling vs. public school vs. private school won’t make or break a kid in their own rights, the connection/relationship (or lack thereof) between parents and kids definitely can.

        In an age where people lead busier lives than ever, and our kids are faced with more and more impactful life decisions at earlier ages (thanks a lot social media!) that bond has never been more important than it is for our kids generation.

        Like most things in life, the quality of the time invested into your children’s upbringing is essential, and as you mentioned, if you build the bond early, hopefully the dividends of responsible young adults will roll down the line.

        Thanks for your perspective on this!!

        Like

  3. Hi Phia! I just found you online. Thank you for taking the time to write this long post and for sharing! I am an educator and author of “peace in Schools: the way to peace on Earth” and my dream is to open a school where the curriculum is all about developing individual skills and giving the children the basis for life, not just knowing about history or math, but also learning about self-esteem, confidence, focus, communication skills and how to take care of their body and mind so they know how to deal with stress and anxiety for instance. I am inspired by your post to keep up my work as I see more and more parents concerned about the current education system. I will keep in touch! Thank you!

    Like

  4. Another great post Phia! You’re totally right that educational choices need more discussion in the FI/FF community. It’s kind of funny that that’s the case, since the choice we make could have a significant financial impact.

    I read about your personal experience with great interest—homeschooling is something I’ve always been interested in. (Even though I long ago realized I don’t have the temperament to homeschool my own kids!)

    Thanks for sharing this thoughtful, enlightening post.

    Like

    1. Thanks Chrissy! Yes there’s no doubt it is an incredibly individual choice that depends on so many factors, not only for the parents but also the kids! And definitely no one size fits all approach. I’m very intrigued by how much is available in the home school community these days – the resources are so plentiful!

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.